Asked by Anonymous · 21 days ago
What will you do to resist AI infrastructure/data centres being built in our communities if they are proposed? It seems like there is a huge disconnect between what the people want and the choices those in power are making. We don’t want data centres EVER in New Tec!
Peter Barbati
Councillor Ward 5
Timely issue. There are differences between Data centers and A.I. centers.
As for the disconnect, there is an agenda and communication is not part of the agenda. Masses of data are collected, collated, and used to promote policies.
In Europe, a "digital passport" is proposed to allow individuals to use the internet...all in the name of promoting safety for minors.
promoting internet safety can be as simple as mandating the use of a filterable suffix (.prn, .adu, etc.) But, although this will allow parents/guardians, libraries, companies,, educators to block access to inappropriate sites, it will not allow for the more profitable ability to control information access.
Bill 34 (Canada) has some strengths, but also some inherent weaknesses, or gray areas, which will allow the government to decide on what is and isn't acceptable.
Getting back to your initial question though, data is not something that can be held in a corral and if it is not built here, it can be built across the highway, with the exact same outcome.
Stopping a data center will not prevent government overreach, changing governments or their policies will. Bill c34 is attached here:
https://www.canada.ca/en/canadian-heritage/services/safe-social-media-act.html
James Dougall
Councillor Ward 1
First of all we do y have the water or electrical grid to support.. I’ll be voting no against
Wendy Gabrek
Councillor Ward 2
I had previously answered the same question above. Thank you :)
Laurie Mortimer
Councillor Ward 3
I will say no to large AI data centres in New Tecumseth.
This isn’t about being against AI or technology. It’s about whether this particular type of development makes sense here, and I don’t believe it does.
We already have serious infrastructure challenges ahead of us. The Town itself says our current water planning does not provide the capacity needed for growth to 2051 and that additional capacity will require significant infrastructure investment. We are currently working on additional groundwater supply, water storage and booster pumping capacity just to support the growth already coming.
I don’t support adding a large AI data centre, with potentially significant electricity and water demands, to that equation. And I don’t believe the relatively small number of permanent jobs typically associated with these facilities justifies dedicating valuable employment land and infrastructure capacity to them.
Our water, power, land and infrastructure are valuable resources. My priority is using them to support our residents, our existing businesses and employment growth that actually brings meaningful jobs to New Tecumseth.
So my answer is clear: if a large AI data centre is proposed in New Tecumseth, I will not support it.
Chris Rapin
Councillor Ward 1
I don't want them, I'll vote against them.
Jaison Waldman
Mayor
Progress requires challenging what we do and why? I support progess and advances in technology. The AI and Data Centre debate is misplaced. Currently I can't find any reason for a technology company to invest in one here, there are numerous options that are better suited. Irrespective, protecting our environment from all forms of pollution and harm is an immediate issue that we should all work on. If the technology makes sense and is not harmful then I would be open to examining the benefits in NewTecumseth.